Friday 12/30/2022 by swittersdc


2022 has been an interesting year of Phish. There have been moments of brilliance, but the music has rarely reached the improvisational peaks of Fall 2021. We discuss this at length on HF Pod. Of course, we don't really know how or why Phish’s playing is different tour to tour. But for me, one major factor is the band’s willingness to take risks, and I think last night’s show was a prime example of taking risks—and seeing it pay off.

A 22-minute opening “Fluffhead” set us off in a great direction. In the 7 minutes post-jam, it starts slowly and melodically, with Page on piano. The tempo wasn’t fast, but that allowed for more interplay between Page and Trey. That could have been the end, as it started to get quieter—but they kept on it and ended up in a really nice jam that, with a little bit of teasing before, ends in “Your Pet Cat.” But we don't really get the typical Your Pet Cat jam, we get a huge, booming climax, making people at MSG, and at home, wonder "what the hell is going on"? And that's exactly where we want to be.

Photo by RJ Bee
Photo by RJ Bee

Bathtub Gin” comes next, and that’s where we see a real willingness to push forward. Around 7 minutes in, it sounds like it would be the typical Gin end in a rocking, upbeat jam. And you can hear Trey considering it, but instead, they hold off.

The jam goes into a slightly darker direction, and then Page hops on the Moog to change course into a spacey direction. Trey gets in on the effects, and we get several minutes of improv before we hit the typical awesome Gin ending.

There are “bliss” jams that we’re used to, with the band building peaks in a major key, with the lights on the crowd, whipping everyone into a frenzy. Those jams are incredible, especially in person. But they can become somewhat predictable when used every show.

This Gin is a great example of holding off, just delaying the inevitable peak in favor of exploration and experimentation—to see what else is out there. This was a really fun one.

We then get the Phish debut of “hey stranger,” which was heavily workshopped on the TAB tour this Fall. It’s got some serious potential, and allows for some experimentation with Trey’s effects. I thihnk this is the gem of the "Mercy" album.

Next comes a“Tube” that I was absolutely convinced was going to go into “Slave to the Traffic Light,” which was right, to the bewilderment of the guy next to me who I said that to. I have been so immersed in Fall ’97 with Undermine, that it just seemed inevitable that we’d have a Tube > Slave.

That had to be the end of the set, right? No, they throw on a “Blaze On” dance party to end what was a tremendous first set.

On the LivePhish recording, before they start “David Bowie,” you can hear someone yell: “Play Tweezer…come on man!” That was not me, but maybe I was thinking that.

Instead, we get the first set two Bowie opener since 11/14/98. It was a welcome surprise, and the jam, which was extremely delicate and melodic, ended with a not-quite-perfect trilling ending, but a fun version nonetheless, and another sign of willingness to push beyond the norm.

Now, we’re really thinking “Tweezer.” Instead, we get an “Everything’s Right.” This one really surprised me, and was another great example of defying the expectations. There’s a nice major key jam forming about 7 minutes in, and on some nights, that’s where it would end. But they blaze on. “Noise rock” is really the only way to describe the jam.

Page, Trey and Mike are all layering in effects, and it feels like they’re really just exploring the space, trying to see where it goes. And somehow it lands back into the song.

My friend says: Tweezer is coming. But we get a mid-set “You Enjoy Myself” that is more than a typical run through of the song and jam. They get back into the noise rock space that was in Everything’s Right, but the tempo is much faster, and it really drives toward a great full-band peak.

Photo by RJ Bee
Photo by RJ Bee

We get this fantastic YEM 10,226 days after their first version at MSG on 12/30/94. That’s 27 years, 11 months, and 29 days. I'm sure there's a hidden message in these numbers somewhere.

I’m really pleased with the “short vocal jam back into a jam” trend we have been seeing this year. We don’t get that here after the vocal jam, but we get another blistering song, in the form of “Ruby Waves.” This ends in a heavy metal rock jam, which was turning heads everywhere.

What an absolute pleasure to hear “Lonely Trip” as a landing space after 65 minutes of incredible music. I see this as the new “Lifeboy,” a breather, but one with a lot of feeling, and a lot of meaning. I feel lucky to have seen 5 of the 12 versions to date. Perfect placement too.

Keep a watch for other ships. And if by chance our vessels pass, perhaps we’ll finally meet at last. During this song, I was thinking about how many people I’ve met through the Phish community, and how with just a few things turning out differently, maybe I would never have met those people. Heavy.

We get a “Back on the Train” and a huge karate-chop filled “Character Zero” to close out the show.

We got a surprise “Guyute” encore (first since 8/15/11), which was … interesting. I appreciate the ambition to go for it and to try for a complex song like that. However, this is literally the only song in the entire catalog that relies entirely on Trey playing extremely precisely and fast. And this one was a mixed bag.

But they pick it back up with a “Possum” encore that allows everyone to get moving one more time before we head out to the pizza shops, halal carts, after parties (shout out to the Jerry Dance Party put on by my good buddy Ed Maier…great post-show hang that’s happening again tonight).

The end of Possum had a repeat "don't do anything we wouldn't do" speech from Trey. He says "how come you get all the fun, and we do all the work, tell us where the party is, we're coming." A few of these mentions "where's the party? we're coming, just tell us where it is" made us think there might be an NYE gag hint in here. Only time will tell.

There’s obviously something special about Phish at MSG, and I think I got what I think is my favorite show of 2022 last night. Can’t wait to go back.

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


, comment by boogisgood
boogisgood Great energy, great show front-to-back. Thanks for the recap
, comment by BuddyBrown
BuddyBrown Ohhh, man -- so that Tweezer you really, really, really wanted was actually played on the twenty-FIFTH anniversary of its F.T.P @MSG, or whatever (I never thought of it like this before, thanks) ...with so many shows, especially at MSG, it's hard to bet on intention, but THEN you get SUCH a monster that you start to fetch the SIGNS.
Anyway, sorry you missed 2018 had your RubyWaves, too.
Here's to more anniversaries
, comment by BruceGZ
BruceGZ Heard that Trey may be a bit under the weather. Had some vocal issues in the 1st set, some coughing. Anyone know if he's good to go? Hope he spent the day with good sleep and hot tea! :)
, comment by Mexi_Cob
Mexi_Cob You don't really know how or why the bands playing is different from tour to tour? Their playing a lot of times is different from show to show or even set to set, it's the nature of improvisational bands.

I truly appreciate your last two reviews, as you are honest and give a good recap, here's hoping you enjoy the remainder of the MSG run.
, comment by HowDidIGetHere
HowDidIGetHere Bravo on the date to date YEM calculator.

I feel the same way about Lonely Trip, a clutch song and perfectly placed in a fantastic set. My favorite attended show of the year as well.
, comment by MMori7
MMori7 First time at MSG for me! I was blessed by this incredible concert!
Thanks RJB for this review!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Support & Mbird
Fun with Setlists
Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour! is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode