Sunday 09/01/2024 by phishnet

DICK'S3 RECAP: MUSIC FOR MONSTERS AND TADPOLES

[We would like to thank Rob (@mikh2wg) for recapping last night's show. -Ed.]

So far, this has been a pretty good vacation. My friend and I got into Denver on Friday. We hadn’t planned it, but our flights landed within 30mins of each other. We pulled into the first taco place we spotted, and it was wonderful. The hotel had our room ready when we got there. We saw a pretty damn good Phish show Friday night. A great start to the trip. My friend recently adopted a four year old and I have had a lot of stress at work so far this year, so we were both ready to relax. We started off Saturday with a hike at Lair O’ the Bear.

It was an easy walk, with the biggest incline coming from the parking lot. There were beautiful views and a babbling creek. Lots of time to look out at nature and muse about all the people who have lived and worked in these hills before us. On the way home, we spotted a sign for something called Dinosaur Ridge so we checked that out too. They had a bunch of dino tracks and some cool rock formations. The brontosaurus bulges were our favorites. Then it was back to the hotel to enjoy a few hours of rest and relaxation before lot dinner and showtime. At this point, I may have blissed out too much on nature and hot tubs to bring an entirely objective eye to Dicks’ Night 3, but I will do my best. I take my responsibility to dot net very seriously.

© 2024 Charlie Miller
© 2024 Charlie Miller

On the way into the venue, we caught sight of the famous prairie dogs with plague. We also found some delicious tamales in the lot and I drank rum out of a coconut. We went into the venue and met up with some fine .netters in section 114.

So the band eventually came out and opened with “46 Days.” I was expecting a swampy groove to open the show, and that was mostly what we got. There was a quick turn into the major key but if you blinked you might have missed it. Mostly they kept this one groovy and down tempo.

Oblivion” came next, the composed section continuing the theme of down tempo swamp funk from the previous song. The jam started out with Trey stepping aside to let the rest of the band set the mood. They started slow and quiet with swelling sounds that reminded me of rising balloons. Trey added in some noodles and then Mike started to go more evil. They did an interesting thing with the tonality here where Trey, Mike and Page took turns being in the major and minor key. It created a weird in between sound that reminded me of what Frankenstein’s monster might listen to if he were in a good mood. From there we moved into an up tempo funk section, and then a classic rock stomp that climbed to a peak. Trey took us home with a little improvised melody that he wove in and out, ABAB style. Once we hit the peak, we crashed back into the song proper.

Axilla II” came next and rocked all our socks. The band clicked together and raged in fine form. Not much of a jam in the outro. Kuroda killed the lights and we got more down tempo, swampy distortion that led to a short delay loop jam into…

© 2024 Charlie Miller
© 2024 Charlie Miller
Bathtub Gin.” This one seemed to be following the normal form of a jazzy climb to a big climax. We took a tangent into more of that weird melodic space where some of the band is sonorous and clean and some of them are dissonant. Fishman kept the beat swinging, so this one sounded like if Frankenstein's Monster opened a jazz bar. That led us to a fiery peak that abruptly switched to the Gin theme to close out. A little miscommunication between Trey and Fish on the last hit gave us a funny little tag at the ending.

Undermind” was a bluesy breather. Mike got to take a solo in this version and he sounded great. Fish also tore it up at the end.

I was pumped for this “Maze” and they did not disappoint. Page’s solo had some telepathic-level interplay between him and Trey. Very locked together. Then Trey took his solo up to the stratosphere. There was some confusion on the final hits at the end, but they managed to land the plane.

I thought “Free” was gonna be the closer, but that was not to be. This version had a nice funk section but it was a little short. Seemed like Page caught everyone off guard with the ending chords.

© 2024 Charlie Miller
© 2024 Charlie Miller
So maybe that's why Trey called “Most Events Aren't Planned” to close. Page did some great work out in front on the boards, but Mike and Trey missed the transition into the outro section. Made the ending a little sloppy and they tried to make up for it with extra heat. Still not gonna complain about this tune, it's always a good time. Time for setbreak, with a little help from Blackalicious' classic Blazing Arrow.

Loving Cup” was a surprise to open set 2. We didn’t get a jammed out version, and if this is in reference to a sport I’m sure you’ll let me know in the comments, but this was still a good way to open the set. I like a warm up tune to stretch the hammies in this spot.

Kill Devil Falls” dropped into the first Set Two Jam Slot and did not disappoint. Fishman went ham on this one and did some amazing work. If you like his feather-light finesse approach to fills, you will want to check out this version. It started out with a section that sounded a bit like “NICU.” Mike hit a driving bass line and Trey pounded those staccato chords in the upper register. Then we transitioned smoothly into something that sounded like Pink Floyd. Not quite ambient, floating through space with a purpose.

From there we headed to a fast-paced funk section in the minor key. This is where Fish took the lead. He entered this liminal space that was similar to how the other guys were playing with tonalities in the first set. Fish, however, was using rhythm to keep us in between two things. He dropped to half time, jumped back up to regular, and pushed everyone into weird new places. It’s Weather Report Tribute night at Frankenstein’s jazz club! Eventually, they resolved into a major key jam that started to build. I pictured horses joyfully running through meadows.

Trey referenced his “NICU”-esuqe staccato chords and that caused Mike to bubble over with ideas in a soul/blues mode. Trey let Page and Mike lead us up into higher ground, but we did not hit a peak. Instead, they landed on these weird double hits and floated out to space. Fish kept a beat going for a while and we ended with a sheet of screaming dissonance that took a hard left turn into…

© 2024 Charlie Miller
© 2024 Charlie Miller
What’s Going Through Your Mind.” This was a first for me (song count at 391!) and I am a fan of this tune. From the manic party description to the scathing chorus, I am here for it. The jam was… unique. I don’t know how to describe it. It was churning through a minor key for a while. The lights looked like tadpoles swimming in a pond. Everyone was playing simple rhythmic phrases but they didn’t lock up in predictable ways. It was like they combined the Plinko jams with the Echo Chamber jams of 2022. Frankenstein’s Monster sits by a pond full of tiny fish after his jazz club closes. Pretty cool, but it will require further analysis. Eventually they rolled over to the major key, so now it was happy tadpole music. Another hard left turn of a segue.

But what a way to go into “Crosseyed and Painless!” The jam was danceable and fast paced. Like “46 Days” in set 1, there was a brief dip into the major. Then they changed keys altogether and Page and Mike sang the, “Still waiting,” part in the new key. Finally, we brought it back to the original key to finish it off. During this song, the crowd in the Mike’s side stand put together a massive rope of glow rings and began passing it through the crowd. Earlier, at Lair o' the Bear Park we had marveled at the power lines strung along mountain peaks and all the work that had gone into them. Now the crowd had constructed their own unbroken line and passed it right in front of us.

Split Open and Melt.” Goddamn it, Phish. You know I’m blissed out on vacation. Why do you keep playing things that are so hard to describe? This “Melt” got dark and weird, as they are wont to do. Lots of free jazz, distortion, and dissonance. Just when I thought they might peel the skin off my face with those lines, the whole band turned on a dime into a triumphant outro. Very cool.

Monsters?” We’re not done? Trey really wails on this one. I love how his voice has been sounding this year. I didn’t hear anything unique about this version, but I thought the placement was good. So “Carini” is the closer? Again, we dipped out toes in the major but this was mostly a minor key shred fest. It was also very fast. Great way to end.

There was an audible groan in our section for “Bug.” This is one of my least favorite Phish songs, so I was participating in that a bit. Didn’t hear any significant flubs, but I’m not a Bug expert. “First Tube,” on the other hand, got everyone celebrating. Not the most inspired choice, certainly, but it got the job done.

I had a great time at this show and don’t have any major complaints. My buddy thought if you combined Friday’s set 1 and encore with Saturday’s set 2, you’d have the perfect show. That might be true, but I’m still smiling.

© 2024 Charlie Miller
© 2024 Charlie Miller

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by mgolia6
mgolia6 Thanks for the review. Thought it was a good marriage of scene and sounds. Maybe it needs an asterisk owing to the fact that it came out of the ambient space from Axilla’s outro, but that segue into Gin was just beautiful. It was patient and sonically delicious. If that were a thing. I imbibed a few heaping helpings of that minute or so this am trying to determine whether it was as good as it sounded live. Feels like it stands up.

Anyway, Phish is in pure bode mode. Excited for what transpires tonight.
, comment by julesmac
julesmac um...er...my wife loves bug and there were cheers in our section...ymmv
, comment by mgolia6
mgolia6 @mgolia6 said:
Thanks for the review. Thought it was a good marriage of scene and sounds. Maybe it needs an asterisk owing to the fact that it came out of the ambient space from Axilla’s outro, but that segue into Gin was just beautiful. It was patient and sonically delicious. If that were a thing. I imbibed a few heaping helpings of that minute or so this am trying to determine whether it was as good as it sounded live. Feels like it stands up.

Anyway, Phish is in pure bode mode. Excited for what transpires tonight.
I completely forgot to mention how I was reveling in those very subtle siren loops that Trey laid down in Maze that lingered lurker style behind the beat for the entirety of the song. That was a standout Maze and those sirens were like pure bliss.
, comment by mgolia6
mgolia6 @julesmac said:
um...er...my wife loves bug and there were cheers in our section...ymmv
I always feel like the grumblings that the opening notes of Bug produces typically dissipate and rocking heads prevail. I never really met a Bug I didn’t like in the end.
, comment by mblum
mblum @julesmac said:
um...er...my wife loves bug and there were cheers in our section...ymmv

Bug is epic. Always has been and always will be for my crew. From Feb 22 ‘03 Cinci snow to Jovi to the encore at Pine knob.

I’ve noticed repeated assumptions even from professional reviewers that phans don’t like certain songs. It’s never the case that all others feel like you do about a song.
, comment by waxbanks
waxbanks > I’ve noticed repeated assumptions even from professional reviewers that phans don’t like certain songs. It’s never the case that all others feel like you do about a song.

I don't see anything in the review that suggests that the reviewer -- probably not a professional, and certainly not getting paid for this volunteer work, like everyone else at phish.net -- assumes that anyone outside his section was groaning when that tune kicked off. Similarly, I bet you don't assume that everyone likes it. It's not a big deal either way; we play for low stakes here.

The opening notes of 'Bug' have always been an incredible buzzkill for me, and the closing notes of 'Bug' always leave me with a warm glow and a hint of '2.0'-flavoured ambivalence. Everyone's mileage varies.

The real question is why anyone likes 'Jibboo' or Classic TAB, but we'll table that.
You must be logged in to post a comment.


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode